It is a technique for correcting defective genes that are responsible for disease development. Ethical issues in and beyond prospective clinical trials of. All requests to carry out any kind of gene therapy on humans must be approved by gtacs research ethics committee rec before it can go ahead. The question at hand is whether it is socially and ethically acceptable to manipulate and alter the genes of humans at all. A human rights approach, was published in bioethics in 2018 and builds on liaos previous writings, including the right to be loved, a 2015 book in which he makes. It is an artificial method that introduces dna into the cells of human body. Ethical considerations of genetic manipulation in sport the. Recently, scientists have also uncovered new crisprcas systems cas that can target rna instead of dna. The first approved gene therapy case at the national institute of health, u. Opinion n4 fmm the gmup of advisers on the ethical implicadons. Dec 12, 2018 prenatal gene therapy offers the earliest possible cure. Germline gene therapy is far more technically difficult than somatic cell therapy. A debate of the ethics of germline gene therapy is presented by from the wellcome genome campus.
In order to explain these problems, one must understand the different types of gene. As omatic gene therapy is highly experimental, the ethical principles to be. What are the ethical issues surrounding gene therapy. May 12, 2020 worlds first gene therapy for glycogen storage disease produces remarkable results. Gene therapy, ethical considerations, challenges and. There were a number of articles dealing with this subject in nature and the journal of the national cancer institute. In this essay, we will consider some of the scientific, social, and ethical.
A report on the ethical issue related to the gene therapy. Although the advent of recombinant dna technology in modern medicine will allow fetal genetic screening and genetic counseling, the vast majority of those born with the disease are likely to be helped by gene therapy approaches. Ethical and social problems of gene therapy springerlink. Gene therapy as a treatment is introduced as described in the article and close observation of gene therapy from medical, ethical and legal view points are necessary and require continuous monitoring and legitimating it. Introduction modern genetics informs us of the biological basis of human life the human genome explaining elements of both the diversity and the variability of human populations and individuals. Ethical considerations of genetic manipulation in sport.
Since the early days of gene therapy at the end of the 1980s, both the scientific community and the public have perceived the ethical and social problems intrinsic to this discipline. Using a bioethical decisionmaking model, students will state the ethical questions, list relevant facts, identify stakeholders, consider. Your genome from the wellcome genome campus provides an introduction to gene therapy and describes several techniques. Additionally, ethical issues relating to genetic modification itself are considered. Some genetic diseases have serious adverse effects on the fetus before birth, and there is hope that prenatal gene therapy could prevent such disease progression.
To discern the ethical issues involved incurrent gene therapy research, to explore theproblems inherent in possible future genetherapies, and to encourage debate within thescientific community about ethical questionsrelevant to both, we surveyed american societyof human genetics scientists who engage inhuman genetics research. Apr 21, 2008 however, gene therapy also raises specific ethical issues and public concerns about the three main fronts. To consider the specific problems linked to the use of genetically modified. Rna interference is considered a new and promising therapeutic approach, but the ethical issues of this method have not been greatly discussed, so this article analyses these issues using the bioethical theory of principles of the american bioethicists, tom l. This modification usually occurs by introducing exogenous dna using viral vectors or other means. Fletcher 1985 journal of medicine and philosophy 10 3. It is hoped that gene therapy can treat or cure diseases for which no other effective treatments are available.
The biology of human gene therapy is very complex, and there are many techniques that still need to be developed and diseases that need to be understood more fully before gene therapy can be used appropriately. Gene therapy is a novel form of molecular medicine which will have a major impact on human health in the coming century. Some ethical issues sa fam pract 2009 478 vol 51 no 6 abstract the major scientific achievement of the twentieth century was the discovery of the double helix, and the mapping of the human genome in 2003. Friedmann and roblin author of a paper in science titled gene therapy for human genetic disease. Moral and ethical issues in gene therapy term paper.
Ethical and regulatory aspects of genome editing blood. Aug 23, 2018 gene therapy is a strategy used to treat disease by correcting defective genes or modifying how genes they are expressed. Biotechnology, ethical issues, social issues, economic factors introduction the term b iotechnology may be defined as the application of engineering principles on bio logical sciences to. Various ethical issues that may be involved regarding gene therapy may be from the discussed below points.
Ethics assessment in research proposals adopting crispr. Background paper the ethics of human genome editing. Ethical and social issues article pdf available in journal of the south carolina medical association 1975 949. By enabling targeted rna recognition and editing, these newer rnatargeting crispr tools have their unique applications ranging from biomedical and biotechnological to the detection of nucleic acids. Gene therapy is an experimental technique that uses genes to treat or prevent disease. The ethical issues for unintended modification of germ cells in the course of an in vivo gene editing therapy are not different from those for therapeutic approaches that would use gene addition. Gtac advises on the ethical acceptability of proposals for gene therapy research on humans. In the future, this technique may allow doctors to treat a disorder by inserting a gene into a patients cells instead of using drugs or surgery. A consensu s no w appear s t o exis t tha t somatic cell gen e therapy for the treatment of seriou s disease is morally correct.
The deaths of patients in clinical trials of cart chimeric antigen receptor tcell therapy bring this ethical question into sharp focus. The pro and con issues regarding gene therapy should be outlined in the body of the paper. Gene therapy consists of a wilful modification of the genetic material in cells of a patient in order to bring about a therapeutic effect. Most surveys of public attitudes toward these ethical issues are already dated and the. Overview summary an extensive discussion of the ethical issues relating to somaticcell gen e therap y has bee n takin g plac e fo r a num ber o f years. Gene therapy introduces or alters genetic material to compensate for a genetic mistake that causes disease. Gene therapy involves replacing a persons genes to treat specific diseases, with the potential to treat diseases such as hivaids, sickle cell anemia, and some types of cancers. Pdf ethical issues of biotechnology, possible risks and. Understanding the science, assessing the evidence, and paying for value. As the potential for the first human trials of somatic cell gene therapy nears, two ethical issues are examined. Ethical issues generally evolve through four stages. We draw on a sample of the bioethics and scientific literatures to address issues that are specific to stem cell research and therapy. Manufacturing, pricing, and reimbursement issues are also addressed. Pdf gene therapy in human beings raises a variety of important ethical, legal and social issues.
Jun 15, 2019 importantly, in july of 2017, an extensive report on the social and ethical issues raised using genome editing as a technology that could influence inherited characteristics in humans was published by the nuffield council on bioethics in the uk. However, many unique technical and ethical considerations have been raised by. Such a view that somatic genome editing with crispr does not raise novel ethical issues. Ethical and social concerns in germline gene therapy ethical concerns about germline therapy have been widely discussed, particularly since the beginning of the human genome project. There is a consensus that gene therapy should be treatment, that is correction in good faith of the disease, rather than enhancement, meaning improvement of the human species. Ethical issues balance of risks and benefits an important ethical issue in research is that benefits must be greater than risks. Gene therapy, the modification of genetic information in living cells to address a mutated gene, has the ability to dramatically change the way diseases are treated, or even cured. The beneficial effects of this therapy and bitter experience of improper use of these methods in medical history shows how. Evolution of ethical debate about human gene therapy. Ethical issues in and beyond prospective clinical trials of human gene therapy. One small edit for humans, one giant edit for humankind.
However, the methods involved and clinical trials raise many questions related to ethical issues that demands a detailed discussion. Early experimental research, though limited, has provided some supporting evidence, and cieszczyk et al. The first gene therapy was successfully accomplished in the year 1989. Regulatory and ethical issues for phase i in utero gene. This is why, in december 1993, the white paper on growth, competitiveness and. Prevailing public perceptions of the ethics of gene therapy. Gene therapy ethical consideration gene therapy, the idea of curing an illness through changing the genetic material of a being, is still in the stages of infancy in terms of scientific procedure, however, the possible ramifications of gene therapy and gene alteration are coming of age within society. Ethical and social concerns in somatic cell gene therapy. Oct 30, 2019 in the late 1990s there was a significant amount of discussion concerning the potential of germline gene therapy and the ethical concerns that accompany it. Somatic gene therapy sgt is similar to other forms of medical treatment in that the goal is to treat or prevent diseases in individuals.
Gene therapy research papers are written for biology or science courses that focus on the pro and cons of gene therapy and the new research on the scientific advantages and disadvantages of various genetic therapies. For more information about the ethical issues raised by gene therapy. In the late 1990s there was a significant amount of discussion concerning the potential of germline gene therapy and the ethical concerns that accompany it. This paper, thus, hopes to contribute to an understanding of the. The amazing power of crisprcas9 gene editing tools and other related technologies has impacted all areas of biology today. It has been a founding tenet of the field of human gene therapy that the human germ line in patients should not be perturbed genetically. Congress also may have a role to play with respect to regulation, research and development, and economic competitiveness associated with crisprcas9 gene editing and future biotechnology products. Gene therapy is a strategy used to treat disease by correcting defective genes or modifying how genes they are expressed. Human gene therapy project muse johns hopkins university. Human gene therapy is a procedure that is being used in an attempt to treat genetic and other diseases. The potential of gene transfer was highlighted by three trials, involving participants with haemophilia b and two types of severe combined immunodeficiencyx linked and adenosine deaminase deficient. The ethical aspects of gene therapy european commission delegation library 2300 m streett nw washington, dc 20037 1. Gene therapy becomes more sophisticated, and the debate over the ethics of dna tinkering grows.
Mar 15, 2012 gene therapy in human beings raises a variety of important ethical, legal and social issues. Rapid progress in biotechnology has introduced a host of pressing ethical and policy issues pertaining to stem cell research. Bioethicists and researchers generally believe that human genome editing for reproductive purposes should not be attempted at this time, but that studies that would make gene therapy safe and effective should continue. Although technical and safety issues suggest that this approach is far from clinical application, gene.
Research in animal models of prenatal gene transfer is actively being pursued. Greater attention must be place on risks, since they may damage living beings or the environment. Gene therapy in human beings raises a variety of important ethical, legal and social issues. The controversy over gene therapy and its effect on cancer nikki maddux the genetic screening dilemma todd quinn gene therapy. Gene therapy discover how it works its types and applications. Nov 30, 2017 beyond safety issues, somatic gene editing in humans does raise ethical, legal and social issues elsi, however, it is suggested to be less challenging to existing ethical and legal frameworks. Human gene therapy human gene therapy what is human gene therapy. Ethical perspectives on rna interference therapeutics. Such a view that somatic genome editing with crispr does not raise novel ethical issues underlies the position of the organising committee of the 2015 international summit on human gene. For a good understanding of the ethical issues of gene therapy, two concepts are essential.
But one of the major differences between germline gene editing and somatic gene editing is that the former introduces edits to all cells in the bodyand potentially to future. In addition, because gene therapy involves making changes to the bodys genetic setup, it raises many unique ethical concerns. A report from the 2016 icer membership policy summit. As with many other new technologies, somatic gene editing with crisprcas9 raises concerns about equitable access to therapies by historically disenfranchised racial and ethnic minorities.
Prenatal gene therapy offers the earliest possible cure. The scientific requirements and the ethical issues associated with each type are discussed. Gene therapy is a technique which involves the replacement of defective genes with healthy ones in order to treat genetic disorders. Bioethics of gene therapy resnik major reference works. The centre for genetics education provides an introduction to gene therapy, including a discussion of ethical and safety considerations. The history of the ethical debate on human gene therapy is examined. The technology that make it possible for modifying genetic material and the possibility of introduction of these modified dna into cells of patients using vectors led to the notion of gene therapy, that helps to correct the action of a defective gene. Christians overall have long viewed scientific research as a proper response to gods commands to take care of the earth and to fill it with unique individuals. Gene therapy has been associated with several problems over the last few decades. Ethical issues in genetic therapy involve the use of genetic science for human good and the avoidance of preventable harms. A discussion of the ethics of gene therapy and genetic engineering is available from the university of missouri center for health ethics. Ethical concerns for healthy individuals include the. The open conflict centered around two early controversial cases.
Ethical issues in human gene therapy leroy walters kennedy institute of ethics, georgetown university. Justice in crisprcas9 research and clinical applications. Somatic cell gene therapy is technically the simplest and ethically the least controversial. Other chapters in help me understand genetics printable chapter pdf 1mb. Secondly, various new technologies continue to propel such debates. Kidshealth from nemours offers a fact sheet called gene therapy and children. Gene therapy is the insertion, alteration, or removal of genes within an individuals cells and biological tissues to treat diseases. The application of crisprcas9 technique involves risks since it may produce off target mutations, which can be. Leroy walters provided a valuable perspective on some of the lessons learned by scientists and ethicists over the 18 years since the first human gene therapy protocol was approved. Firstly, there exists the risk of deliberate alteration in the human germ line, which may change the inherited nature of human beings.
Ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy stem cell. Ethical issues regarding novel gene modifications are not new with regard to somatic applications, given that they pertain to other types of somatic gene therapy. The following subject is the biggest concern to those who have been reading into the topic gene therapy. Consider the rapid development of gene therapies, often combined with stem cell modifications, to combat cancer. The term gene therapy encompasses at least four types of application of genetic engineering for the insertion of genes into humans. It has also raised ethical concerns, particularly with regard to the possibility of generating heritable changes in the human genome socalled germline gene editing.
Many ethical, social and safety concerns are being raised on the use of human genetic engineering. Miah 10 suggested that gene therapy could be used to help athletes recover from injury more effectively and efficiently. The prospect of human phase i in utero gene transfer studies raises important regulatory and ethical. First and foremost ethical issue regarding this technique is the categorization of genes as either badgood. Ehrbar1 1 student of doctoral studies in sports management at the united states sports academy abstract new technologies are currently being developed that will enable medical professionals to modify genes for medicinal purposes. Crisprcas9 is a rapidly developing gene editing technology that will soon have many clinical applications. In the uk, the gene therapy advisory committee gtac was set up in 1993 to regulate the use of gene therapy.
Since the early 1990s, investigators have toiled to establish the transfer of genes to human somatic cells as a valid therapy fig 1. The techniques used involve administrating a specific dna or rna sequence. On one hand, the technologies for gene transfer are still largely experimental and thus pose important safety issues. One of the main issues is the lack of knowledge about the longterm effects of the therapy and the field is. To discern the ethical issues involved in current gene therapy research, to explore the. Ethical issues in and beyond prospective clinical trials.
647 899 1038 863 1443 5 110 357 1078 293 622 1185 1462 261 891 428 649 1279 1148 1481 681 1328 1620 541 117 46 1307 1347 817 583 1495 251 376 870 965 740 1243 848 275