Quantify organisations current supply chain performance. Operational daily production and distribution planning. Spendolini 1992 defines benchmarking as a continuous and systematic process for evaluating the products, services, and work processes of organizations that. The metrics are the same its the targets that differ by segments. The process of benchmarking, benchlearning and benchaction article pdf available in the tqm magazine 1. Benchmarking healthcare logistics processes a comparative case study of danish and us hospitals. This report will answer that question and point to areas for improvement. Benchmarking healthcare logistics processes a comparative case. Benchmarking storage and warehousing in the process. Within the warehousing and distribution industry benchmarking has traditionally been.
Logistics second edition and apqcs open standards benchmarking in logistics, discuss ontime and. Benchmarking is increasing in popularity as a tool for continuous improvement. This subscription based supply chain and logistics service is designed to provide you with an annual strategic snapshot of your supply chain performance. Benchmarking defined benchmarking is the continuous process of comparing ones business processes and performance metrics to industry bests andor best practices from other industries. The benchmark process combines the scor metric hierarchy with mpis historical data population which includes more than 1,000 companies, 2,000 supply chains, 5,000 sites and a 20year history of collaboration, to offer the most comprehensive supply chain. Logistics processes in hospitals are vital in the provision of patient care. By whatever name it is the sinuous, gritty, and cumbersome process by which companies move material, parts, and products to customers. Benchmarking is a critical tool to be used to understand the current state and gaps that exist in a supply chain. Its use is welldeveloped within the automotive industry automotive benchmarking, where it is vital to design products that match precise user expectations, at minimal cost, by applying the best technologies available worldwide.
Benchmarking distribution, logistics and the supply chain process conference paper pdf available july 1995 with 403 reads how we measure reads. Trbs national freight cooperative research program nfcrp report 21. Browse benchmarking, logistics and manufacturing content selected by the supply chain brief community. My first step was to engage benchmarking success bms to understand what the best for each business really meant from an independent source. Sep 19, 2019 benchmarking, or goal setting, allows a company to assess the opportunities they have for the logistic control of a number of areas in its supply chain.
Different business activities under the microscope of logistics benchmarking may be manufacturing or supplier costs, wholesaler fees, transportation payments, and opportunity costs. The cilt benchmarking forum consists of many of the industrys leading companies and has emerged as the industrys premier source on transport, logistics and operational performance metrics. Pdf the process of benchmarking, benchlearning and benchaction. This workbook complements cscmps supply chain management process. Using a logistic benchmarking process can provide a company with some estimate of.
Benchmarking allows logistics managers to find out how competitive. A proper vcp will define expectations and benchmarks for the vendor, have a. When indicators are used to benchmark performance internationally and. Pdf the process of benchmarking, benchlearning and. Exploit benchmarking services to help calibrate logistics costs and performance published. Supply chain benchmarking tools supply chain improvement. Care must be exercised to ensure that all factors are taken into consideration and that benchmarking is part of the continuous improvement process. Improvements and benefits when shifting parts exchanging process in a household appliance organization emerson d. The award was presented at the council of logistics management. Benchmarking green logistics performance with a composite. Furthermore, managers in healthcare logistics are provided with a list of decision parameters relevant for designing and benchmarking processes. Pdf benchmarking distribution, logistics and the supply chain.
Benchmarking success now also provide an on line benchmarking service to help you drive business improvement with appropriate benchmarks. The benchmark process combines the scor metric hierarchy with mpis historical data population which includes more than 1,000 companies, 2,000 supply chains, 5,000 sites and a 20year history of collaboration, to offer the most comprehensive supply chain benchmarking service available in the industry. Handbook on applying environmental benchmarking in freight. The benchmarking success warehousing benchmarking tool is effectively a warehousing audit tool. Its focus is to employ careful analysis of industry data to compare performance, examine industry trends, answer critical business questions, and identify best practices. Next, an analytical model and datacollection tool were developed and a datacollection approach was subsequently selected. Benchmarking healthcare logistics processes a comparative. The most important decision criteria were related to quality, security of supply and employee engagement. The metrics are categorized in five performance attributes.
Freight cost control is a critical element in evaluating and seeking improvement for many companies, big or small. This 89page supply chain kpi benchmarking report includes benchmarking data for 40 supply chain operations, or management, kpis including perfect customer order rate, backorder rate, days inventory outstanding and more. To enable best practice benchmarking, the hospital logistics process was divided into several components to facilitate analysis. Understand interdependencies and tradeoffs between metrics. The gartner supply chain hierarchy of metrics benchmarking. An ahp approach in benchmarking logistics performance of the postal industry felix t. He joined logistics bureau group back in 2009 and commenced by running the benchmarking business known as benchmarking success. Conference paper pdf available july 1995 with 423 reads. Benchmarking efforts can stimulate organizational learning, and enhance business performance and industry competitiveness. Improving healthcare logistics processes provides an opportunity for reduced healthcare costs and better support of clinical processes. Benchmarking transportation processes with tms data. Inbound freight needs to run as smoothly as possible for the best customer experience. No, process benchmarking is never an ad hoc activity and instead is a structured process whereby. As you can see, a proper vcp is necessary to have competitive logistics management processes.
The study contributes to the limited literature on healthcare logistics benchmarking. Whether you want to learn which supply chain measures to use with our process classification framework pcf, adapt best practices, or benchmark your supply chain activities, we can help. To assist during the covid19 pandemic, weve developed 3 critical rapid action remote consulting services. Aug 17, 2017 these are the process modeling, performance measurement, and best practices pillars. How well is your dc performing compared to similar operations. Pdf benchmarking distribution, logistics and the supply.
Benchmarking establishes methods of measuring each area in terms of units of output as well as cost. This handbook addresses air emissions at several different levels, including vehicle fleets. It is essentially aimed at improving the business and operational practices that. Benchmarking transportation processes with tms data inbound.
Key performance metrics from a recent werc benchmark study. To develop a new benchmarking process for continuous improvement against the market leader, and report a case study in the postal industry by employing the proposed. Dimensions typically measured are quality, time, and cost. Supply chain and logistics benchmarking logistics bureau. In order to improve the quality and efficiency of hospitals, they can be viewed as a logistical system in which integration is a critical factor for performance. In general, it is important to ensure that the process is linked to the organizational and logisticssupply chain strategy. The report provides a stepbystep overview of the benchmarking process and describes a framework for applying this process to freight carriers, shippers, and freight hubs. Many companies have some process to manage expedited receipts. Without knowledge of the costs, it has been challenging to engage in benchmarking the logistics process properly. Logistics management includes numerous complex processes including procurement, transportation, and logistics planning, just to name a few. The process adopts a business process management bpm logic with two core benchmarking analytic steps. Logistics development strategies and performance measurement.
This time i wanted to highlight our content featuring logistics benchmarks. One method is to perform a series of benchmarking tests for price, quality, design, efficiency, and cost effectiveness. Supply chain management benchmarking report pdf opsdog. This handbook addresses air emissions at several different levels, including vehicle fleets, facilities, organizations, and transportation corridors.
This paper develops a national logistics benchmarking process based on the logistics performance index lpi database maintained by the world bank. Continual improvement the benchmarking process is a continual one. The performance measurement pillar, which is the one used for benchmarking, is essentially a hierarchy of key performance indicators kpis, comprising more than 150 metrics organised into two levels. The success of the automotive sector in mexico and the assembly processes on which. National logistics performance monitoring in mexico and north america. Benchmark your logistics processes supply chain brain.
The gartner supply chain benchmarking database includes 17 metrics across seven core process areas spanning multiple industries and geographies. Warehousing and fulfillment process benchmark and best. As mentioned, process benchmarking is not the same thing as a famtrip or getting a showaround another business which can of course be valuable in its own right. It is essentially aimed at improving the business and operational practices that your company is already following. Some knowledge and a practical dent is all that is needed to make such a process a success. Benchmarking generally refers to the process of measuring ones performance against a set of preestablished standards by the world or your competitors present in the same business process as you. I received a question a while back from a client, a supply chain director at a process manufacturer. When used in conjunction with tms capabilities, transportation benchmarking offers a valuable way for shippers to gain a competitive edge within their logistics operations in todays challenging landscape. Understand the structure of scor there are over 250 scor metrics that are organized in a hierarchical and codified structure from organization level 1 to process level 2 to diagnostic level 3. Functional benchmarking is a comparison to similar or identical practices e. Global supply chain benchmarking study for the tire industry. Exploit benchmarking services to help calibrate logistics. Jul 27, 2015 benchmarking efforts can stimulate organizational learning, and enhance business performance and industry competitiveness. Benchmarking distribution, logistics and the supply chain process.
A process benchmarking exercise often leads an organization to more clearly understand and articulate its current processes, giving the organization a better grasp of its starting point as it considers potential change initiatives. In my last blog post i highlighted apqcs recently released collection of key procurement benchmarks. Based on these decision criteria, performance indicators were developed to enable benchmarking of logistics processes in healthcare. Handbook on applying environmental benchmarking in freight transportation explores how benchmarking can be used as a management tool in the freight and logistics industry to promote environmental performance. Pdf benchmarking the hospital logistics process researchgate.
Logistics is the art of managing the supply chain and science of managing. Benchmarking of all operations milestone payments 12. Establish the gap between current performance and worlds best practice. Logistics and warehousing performance assessment apqc. Therefore, for the benefit of corporate executives, students and the interested general populace, the key steps in the benchmarking process are highlighted below. To develop a new benchmarking process for continuous improvement against the market leader, and report a case study in. Maintaining high efficiency is the only way to ensure customer demands are met without significantly increased costs.
Benchmarking warehousing and distribution operations is an appropriate and popular. Global supply chain benchmarking study for the tire industry executive summary global supply chain benchmarking study for the tire industry executive summary 7 the supply chain of today needs to be. Benchmarking and best practices the proaction group. Oct 25, 2011 purpose this paper aims to discuss the development and use of a green logistics performance index glpi for easy comparison of performance among industries and countries. Benchmarking warehousing and distribution operations 1. In the process manufacturing industry, storage often does not involve warehouses that store cases and pallets.
Global supply chain benchmarking study for the tire industry executive summary global supply chain benchmarking study for the tire industry executive summary 5 despite high inventory levels and logistics costs, the industry witnesses relatively higher order cycle time. Benchmarking, or goal setting, allows a company to assess the opportunities they have for the logistic control of a number of areas in its supply chain. Benchmarking, logistics and manufacturing supply chain brief. No, process benchmarking is never an ad hoc activity and instead is a structured process whereby you seek to compare one of your key processes. Greg aimi this research helps logistics professionals understand where to get and how to use logisticsspecific benchmark data, the benefits and drawbacks of supply chain benchmarking providers, and how to identify the best. Call it distribution or logistics or supply chain management. This paper aims to discuss the development and use of a green logistics performance index glpi for easy comparison of performance among industries and countries. A benchmarking scheme for supply chain collaboration togar m. It uses the survey data collected from the home electronic appliance industry in china and japan as an example to demonstrate the index development process and compare the performance of green logistics gl practices. If youd like to find out more about benchmarking your supply chain with help from bms, please feel free to stop by at the website and check out the services on offer steven thacker is a contributing author to the supply chain secrets book series.
These areas include productivity, inventory accuracy, shipping accuracy, storage density, and bintobin time. These articles, based on the report blueprint for success. After implementing the recommendations, companies continue to benchmark and make improvements to stay competitive. Logistics, or logistics management is the process of planning and implementing procedures for the efficient flow of goods in and out of the organization in order to satisfy customer needs. Logistics also covers the management flow either between certain points of interest in order to meet the requirements set by your clients or corporation. Steps in benchmarking process the national academies press.
Benchmarking success maintains a database of multilevel kpis from more than 800 different supply chains, spanning a range of industries. Benchmarking is a disciplined method of establishing performance goals and quality improvement projects based on industry best practices. This simplified process for supply chain benchmarking logistics in supply chain management can reduce your operational costs and create significant savings in bulk, truckload, ltl, rail, intermodal and international shipment modes. The benchmarking process is relatively uncomplicated. Logistics is the implementation and organization of operations being conducted by an organization at all steps in the supply process. Organizations that faithfully use benchmarking strategies achieve a cost savings of 30 to 40 per cent or more. What is strategic benchmarking when you include strategic benchmarking in your planning, you can compare your improvements in strategic performance to that of performance leaders in your field of activity in addition to comparing them to the past performance of your own business. This process is usually referred to as technical benchmarking or product benchmarking. Benchmarking warehousing and distribution operations isye 6202fall 2003 1 introduction benchmarking warehousing and distribution operations is an appropriate and popular. Global supply chain benchmarking study for the tire.
799 177 1463 817 961 899 324 862 176 1588 277 211 1420 1522 655 1475 1543 1544 951 229 105 1463 1250 1617 789 58 329 451 475 497 10 1257 613 545 348 1443 22